Go to the french version You are here  homepage | News

The opinion of the french on pesticide use in agriculture 

 65% of the people interviewed understand the need for the use of pesticides 

75% know or suppose that manufacturers need to obtain product registration 

It is in drinking water and in soil that the French think there might be a very important pesticide hazard (respectively 58% and 43%) 

Integrated farming appears as a credible alternative to "all organic" farming (47%/52%) 

More about this survey



The opinion of the french
European product registration
Pesticide tax
 
European product registration


1. Annex I (" Positive list ")

In order for a new product to be approved, its active substance must be registered on the positive list in Annex I (European Commission Directive 91/414/EEC published in July 1991).

There are two ways for a compound to be listed in Annex I :

- New active substance (not present on the market by July 1993) to be evaluated under Directive 91/414/EEC requirements (Acibenzolar-S-methyl, Azimsulfuron, Azoxystrobin, Cyclanilide, Fenhexamid, Flupyrsulfuron-methyl, Kresoxim-methyl, Paecilomyces fumosoroseus, Phosphate ferrique, Prohexadione-calcium, Pymetrozin, Pyraflufen-ethyl, Spiroxamin)
- Existing active substance being reviewed

The first step of review procedure resulted in 1994 in the drawing up of a prioritary list containing 90 active substances.

Results : 

63 active substances are still under examination

11 active substances are listed in Annex I
. Imazalil, Fluroxypyr, Esfenvalerate, Bentazone, Triasulfuron, Metsulfuron-methyl, Lambda-cyhalothrine, amitrole, diquat, pyridate, thiabendazole

16 active substances abandoned :

DNOC, Dinoterb, Pyrazophos, Monolinuron, Lindane, Quintozene, Chlozolinate, Azinphos-ethyl, Cyhalothrin, Fenvalerate, Ferbame, Prophame, Parathion-ethyl, Permethrin, Zineb, Tecnazen.

For active substances that are being reviewed, previous sales approvals remain valid.
The second list of active substances to be reviewed was published end of February 2000 in the framework of European regulations. From this date onwards, companies concerned had 6 months to notify their intention to support the compounds concerned (till 31/08/2000). If they do not wish to support them, use suspension and market withdrawal will be announced authorizing a usage deadline until end of July 2003. This rule notwithstanding, derogations for agronomical reasons will be permitted if they concern use for minor purposes. Among these 148 active substances on the second list , there are 70 organophosphate insecticides and 22 carbamates.

Pesticide active substances not present on the first or second review list, will also need to follow the same process over time and companies will have to notify what their intentions are. This process will be taking place in two steps : one declaration of intention followed by a detailed notification.
The Standing Committee of the European Commission will publish the list of active substances which have been notified early 2001.
Active substances that have not been notified will be withdrawn from the market. Nevertheless, if one claims strong agronomic needs, Member States can allow derogations with the Commission agreement.

Current state of Annex I :

 


Acibenzolar-S-methyl (Fungicide, Syngenta)
Amitrole (Herbicide, Nufarm) 
Azimsulfuron (Herbicide, DuPont de Nemours)
Azoxystrobin (Fungicide, Syngenta)
Bentazone* (Herbicide, BASF Agro)
Cyclanilide (Growth regulator, Aventis CropScience)
Diquat (Herbicide, Syngenta)
Esfenvalerate* (Insecticide, Sumitomo)
Fenhexamid (Fungicide, Bayer)
Flupyrsulfuron-methyl (Herbicide, DuPont de Nemours)
Fluroxypyr* (Herbicide, DowAgroSciences)
Imazalil* (Fungicide, Janssen)
Kresoxim-methyl (Fungicide, Basf Agro)
Lambda-cyhalothrine* (Insecticide, Syngenta)
Metsulfuron-methyl* (Herbicide, DuPont de Nemours)
Paecilomyces fumosoroseus (Insecticde, Thermo Trilogy Corporation)
Phosphate ferrique
Prohexadione-calcium (Growth regulator, BASF Agro)
Pymetrozin (Insecticide, Syngenta)
Pyridate (Herbicide)
Pyraflufen-ethyl (Herbicide, Nihon Nohyaku Co Ltd)
Spiroxamine (Fungicide, Bayer)
Thiabendazole (Fungicide)
Triasulfuron* (Herbicide, Syngenta)

( following review)




2. Temporary Sales Approval

In each Member State, derogations have been foreseen by Directive 91/414/EEC allowing a temporary sales approval for 3 years, renewable for speciality products containing active substances not yet listed in Annex I, but which have been estimated to be acceptable by European institutions and assessed on a National level.
Conditions required for European acceptability :

· An " active substance " registration needs to be presented in one European Union country and agreed by this country’s authorities.
The registration has to be transferred to European authorities for confirmation of its opinion and publication of the decision.
End of April 2000, 63 pesticide active substances not listed with Annex I were declared acceptable. This explains the temporary sales approvals given in France these past years.

For more detailed information, please refere to the article
  " European registration : positive list, review list, notification calendar…What’up? "
  in  Phytoma - La Défense des Végétaux n°527 – May 2000





Pesticide tax


Environmental tax reforms

The general tax on pollutants (TGAP in France) which has been acknowledged under the Finance Law in 1999 that resulted from the government's aim to reform environmental taxation, has been enlarged by the law for financing the social security in 2000 : in future, it will apply, among other products, on pesticides used for agriculture or similar purposes.
This new tax, which replaces a certain number of taxes that had previously been collected separately by ADEME (Agency for Development, for the Environment and for Energy Control) was enforced on January 1, 2000. It was supposed to yield 300 million French Francs the first year for the government budget.

This tax uses the same calculation method as is used for excise, and is based on a mix of toxicological and ecotoxicological criteria (possibly aggravated by hazard phrases). A scale is associated with it representing 7 categories going from 0 FF/tonne to 11 000 FF/tonne for most heavily taxed products. The amount of the tax is based on the amount of active substance sold on the National market. The tax is to be paid by the manufacturer or the importer .
It is of course too early to measure the impacts of the pesticide tax on volumes sold, production costs or commercial cycles. One can, however, regret that the money collected will not benefit any consistent policies on environmental protection asked for by most players in the agricultural sector for the past few years, and which was the initial aim of the Ministry of Environment.